Approaches to teaching writing (Entry 8)
Six Approaches to Writing
According to Vicki Mcquitty: 6 Approaches to Writing
Instruction in Elementary School
Penmanship
Approach
According to research, the best
handwriting teaching takes place in brief, frequent, and structured classes
(Christensen, 2009). The emphasis of lessons should be on writing quickly and
naturally rather than on creating flawless letters or placing the letters
precisely between the lines. Lessons should last 10 to 20 minutes each day. It
is beneficial if teachers first show students how to form each letter before
giving them time to practice writing individual letters, words, and lengthier
texts. Both handwritten and cursive writing programs are available, and they
frequently teach the letters in a certain order that has been found to aid in the
development of handwriting. However, teaching children to write by hand
shouldn't start until they can form letters quickly. Once their handwriting is
automatic, students should practice writing for real audiences and reasons.
Rules-Based
Approach
Children are taught how to write
words and sentences correctly as part of rules-based training. It involves
tasks like classifying words into parts of speech, locating sentence components
like subjects and predicates, learning and using subject-verb agreement and
pronoun usage norms, and honing punctuation, capitalization, and spelling
skills. Sentence correction is a typical exercise. Teachers give students
sentences that contain grammatical problems and urge them to fix them. To
practice using language, students may also compose their own creative
sentences. For instance, they can be instructed to compose a sentence that
properly utilizes a particular adjective or homonym. Prefixing or suffixing
lists of words, linking phrases with conjunctions, and turning sentence
fragments into entire sentences are other exercises.
Process Approach
Process writing instruction focuses
on the process of composing texts. In this approach, children learn to
brainstorm ideas, write rough drafts, and revise and edit those drafts. Process
writing emerged in the 1970s, sparked by teachers’ growing rejection of a
rules-based approach. At the same time, professional authors, such as the
Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Donald Murray (Murray, 1968), began to
advocate a “workshop” approach to writing instruction that engaged students in
the same writing process that published authors used. Soon thereafter,
researchers began to study writers as they composed original texts (Emig, 1971;
Hayes & Flower, 1980).
Genre Approach
The focus of genre-based writing
training is on learning how to compose a variety of texts. The idea that
writing is situational, and that what constitutes "excellent" writing
relies on the context, purpose, and audience, is the foundation of the genre
concept. For instance, writing an SMS to a buddy and writing an essay are two
quite distinct writing tasks. The author and reader already have similar backgrounds;
hence no background information is necessary for a "good" text
message to effectively and casually transmit ideas.
Strategy
Approach
Children who get writing education using strategy methods learn the
planning, drafting, and editing techniques utilized by professional writers. These
techniques are step-by-step instructions that walk students through every stage
of the writing process. This method would be taught by the instructor in the
following steps: 1) provide the underlying knowledge necessary for students to
use the approach; 2) talk about the method and how it would enhance students'
writing; 3) show the thought processes needed while putting the strategy into
practice; 4) Offer assistance as students utilize the method, such as by
collaborating with a partner; 5) let students use the strategy on their own.
Multimodal Approach
Writing training that uses multiple media acknowledges that modern writers use different writing styles than those of the past. We also—and possibly more frequently—compose digitally in addition to traditional, linear, paper-based texts. Digital writing involves more than just typing on a computer instead of writing by hand. Authors can become proficient in creating each of the several communication types used by digital writing. Take a look at a standard website. It may include written words, images, audio, video, and text boxes that let readers post their own ideas in addition to written words. It takes different abilities to plan and coordinate all of these diverse aspects than it does to write a novel using only words.
I liked how you gave in depth definitions on the various approaches to writing. The video was an extra bonus for added information.
ReplyDeleteYes the penmanship and rule-base approach are crucial in writing, but I believe that the genre and mutlimodal approach will work best for children in the 21st century classroom. I say this because, genre sparks children interest as it varies in topics, cognitive levels, words counts, etc. While the multimodal is perfect for all learners as it uses visual, auditory, linguistic and kinesthetic modes of learner. We have different types of learners within our classroom and one mode will not be suitable for all. As teachers, we have to practice being inclusive and ensure that all students are learning and are on the same page.
ReplyDelete